Vermont Public is independent, community-supported media, serving Vermont with trusted, relevant and essential information. We share stories that bring people together, from every corner of our region.

© 2026 Vermont Public | 365 Troy Ave. Colchester, VT 05446

Public Files:
WVTI · WOXM · WVBA · WVNK · WVTQ
WVPR · WRVT · WOXR · WNCH · WVPA
WVPS · WVXR · WETK · WVTB · WVER
WVER-FM · WVLR-FM · WBTN-FM

For assistance accessing our public files, please contact hello@vermontpublic.org or call 802-655-9451.
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Join the Brave Little State team on December 8 in St. Albans to mingle with fellow listeners and choose a topic for a future episode. Get tickets and details here.

How do Vermonters find and keep community?

A woman digs into a garden bed.
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Ash Hoyt asked Brave Little State about how Vermonter's are combating loneliness. When she's in need of community, she heads to her neighborhood garden — "a place that feels less lonely to me on days I feel lonely," she says.

Our quest to talk to Vermonters about loneliness and community takes us from a neighborhood garden to a beloved local bar.

Brave Little State is Vermont Public’s listener-powered journalism podcast. Every episode begins with a question. Today, Ash Hoyt in Burlington asked:

“I've heard from countless Vermonters that the loneliness pandemic heavily impacts them. Me too. How do Vermonters find and keep community?”

Note: Our show is made for the ear. We highly recommend listening to the audio. We’ve also provided a transcript. Transcripts are generated using a combination of robots and human transcribers, and they may contain errors.

Loading...

Bouts of loneliness

Josh Crane: From Vermont Public and the NPR Network, this is Brave Little State. I'm Josh Crane.

Ash Hoyt: So we grew snap peas and carrots from seeds, and those were the most successful.

Josh Crane: I'm in the Archibald Community Garden in Burlington's Old North End. It's late fall, and Ash Hoyt is giving me a postmortem on this year’s garden plot.

Ash Hoyt: Let’s see, I tried to grow cauliflower, and that did not go well.

Josh Crane: It's a small raised bed, one of a couple dozen in the garden tended by local residents. Community garden plots aren't as common in much of Vermont, but they're valuable resources here in the state's most densely populated neighborhood.

Ash Hoyt: So it's nice to share and give extra food when you have it. I just, like, love things that help people form community and be in spaces to talk about amazing things and also really challenging things. 

And this is also, I wanted to meet here with you because this is also a place that feels low stakes when I'm feeling lonely. Before you got here, there was someone here that I know, who— I don't know her other than the fact that she also has a plot here.  So yeah, I think that this is a place that feels less lonely to me on days I feel lonely.

Josh Crane: Those lonely days are what inspired Ash to submit a question to the show.

Ash Hoyt: Hi, my name is Ash Hoyt. And my question is, "I've heard from countless Vermonters that the loneliness pandemic heavily impacts them. Me too. How do Vermonters find and keep community?"

Ash Hoyt smiles at the camera while standing in her community garden
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Ash poses with her community garden plot.

Josh Crane: Ash has experienced bouts of loneliness at different points in her life. One of the hardest was about eight years ago, which was her first winter living alone in Vermont. She was doing the long distance thing with her partner at the time, her now-husband, and she had a couple of friends in Burlington who she only saw occasionally.

Ash Hoyt: It was a lot of: Go to work, come home, and then it was like, "OK, now what?" You know? And then it was, like, from 5:00 to 10:00 you're alone, and I think that experiencing winter and the darkness felt really grim and never-ending.

Josh Crane:  Ash is no longer a newcomer around here, and she's feeling much more connected to her community. She’s got her garden. She runs this pop-up nail salon from time to time in a nearby park as a way of bringing people together. She even helps college students connect with their neighbors as part of her job at UVM.

But there are certain types of connections that still feel elusive.

Ash Hoyt: And I think as a 33-year-old woman, currently with no kids, making friends is, like, the hardest thing I've ever done as an adult.

Josh Crane: And like Ash mentioned in her question, a lot of other Vermonters feel this way, too.

Your friends & neighbors

Josh Crane: Question-asker Ash Hoyt is trying to build a strong community in Burlington. It has taken many years to take shape. And it’s still a work-in-progress.

And, while I realize this is not exactly breaking news, Ash is not alone … in sometimes feeling alone.

A recent Vermont Public poll surveyed hundreds of Vermonters on a slew of issues — including loneliness. More than half of respondents said they had, quote, "just a few" nearby friends or relatives — or none at all — who they could rely on for help or support. That's up almost 10 percentage points from a similar poll in 2019.

Josh Crane: We called some of the people who responded to this survey to hear more about their answers.

Bryan: My response to the survey was recognition that I don't have any true close friends out here, and that's a bummer.

Cristine:  I have a large community of people that I know, but that's really different than people that you can rely on. 

Jack:  I have many acquaintances. I have very few friends. 

Marylynn:  And the older you get, the less friends you have because they're all dying too.

Jack:  Yeah, I'm very lonely. 

Philip: When I go skiing, I see friends that I ski with. Also, the same as people that I go hiking with. We don't seem to make connections beyond that activity. 

Jack:  I'm sure if, you know, I put something out on Front Porch Forum of, "Hey, I need help moving wood," or something, people would respond to that. But they're there because they're good people. They're not necessarily there because of me. 

Marylynn:  I grew up in Brattleboro. My mother came from a large family, so I had a lot of cousins. And I still have friends that I went to high school with. 

Bryan: There is a definite sense of outsider. I love the people that we, we meet up here. Love the friends. I love the area. It's just, it can only go so far. 

Erika:  I became a born-again Christian a few years ago, and when I did, I joined a church, and through that church you instantly, at least it feels instantly, that you have a group of people who will be with you through thick and thin, as they say. My only experience of that has ever been through a church. 

Cristine: Before my illness worsened, I did not feel lonely. I had so many people and so many things to do, and I had so much energy, and now that I can't do that, yeah, there's a lot of loneliness. So many of the people who you know, swore that we were friends and that we would, you know, help each other did not show up. 

Erika:   Yes, I do feel like I can rely on them. I just had somebody today offer to, "I'm going to Trader Joe's. Do you want me to pick something up while I'm there?" You know,  I lived other places briefly in my life, and I never had that kind of community connection.

Bryan: I don't get lonely, I mean, to, to be perfectly blunt about it. Um, so life is, life is too inherently interesting to be either bored or lonely, in my opinion. That, that's just me, though. I know a lot of people are. 

Jack:  Loneliness in general seems to be treated as a personal failing. If you're lonely, it's your own fault. You haven't gone out and met people, you know? You haven't, uh, haven't made enough of an effort. You haven't changed yourself. 

Philip: I've gotten pretty lazy about it, uh, more recently, and I, and I was, I think about how I should work harder to make, uh, more friends. 

Cristine: When I think about, like, what would make me feel less lonely, like, having the friends who really get me where I do not need to mask one single bit, like that is, that's so freeing. I wish everybody had that.

Ash Hoyt: Loneliness feels like a taboo topic sometimes. It’s like, if you say you are lonely you’re, like, you’re scaring other people or, like, unworthy. But to be human is to be lonely.

Josh: I’m back in the community garden with our question-asker, Ash Hoyt. I ask her what it feels like to be lonely.

Ash Hoyt: It feels low, but it also feels so high. It's like the perfect combo of feeling really low and also, like, anxious about it. Um, like, "What's wrong with me? Is this ever gonna end?" Um, so I guess that's how it feels for me. 

Do you feel like that?

Josh Crane: I get really inside of my own head.

Ash Hoyt: Oh, it's the best, isn't it? (Laughter)

Josh Crane: So, uh, sometimes when I am alone, I feel the least lonely because I can just be myself. And I can like— there's a presence even when you're alone.

Ash Hoyt: Of course.

Josh Crane: Um, and then sometimes when I'm in more social settings, I will feel more, like, inside my own head. And therefore I'll feel lonelier.

Ash Hoyt: Totally, yeah. I mean, being alone, like, being comfortable being alone with yourself, people struggle with that forever.

I don't know if you feel like this, but, like, I'll go out to dinner by myself, like, you can leave when you wanna leave, like sit at the bar, chat with the bartender. Like, um, yeah, I love doing stuff alone, too.

Ash Hoyt shows us around
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Ash finds joy in solitude and community at the garden.

Josh Crane:  What Ash says about going to a bar by herself gets me thinking about all the different ways people find connection around here. There are the more organized ways, like Ash’s community garden and her nail pop-ups. I see postings about things like singing groups, contra dances and women's clubs on my town’s listserv all the time.

And then there are places like bars. You don't have to sign up for anything or share a particular interest with anyone. You can just show up, sit at the bar, and see who you meet. Which makes them pretty perfect places to talk to people about loneliness and community.

Josh Crane: Now I'm like, maybe I should bring my recorder to a restaurant and sit at the bar and talk to a bartender.

Ash Hoyt: You should totally do that.

The Olde Northender

The Olde Northender in Burlington's Old North End
Burgess Brown
/
Vermont Public
The Olde Northender in Burlington's Old North End.

Tommy Dubuc: How was your weekend? … Oh, you must've had fun this weekend. We're out of vodka again.

Josh Crane: I'm doing something I've never really done before: sitting at a bar alone.

After hearing all the people who responded to the Vermont Public poll, it’s clear that you can’t make sweeping statements about community in Vermont. It probably looks and feels different in every town, every neighborhood … maybe even every bar. So, rather than try to define it in the abstract, I’m zooming in about as close as I can get: one neighborhood, one bar, one barstool.

I’m sitting in roughly the center stool at the Olde Northender, a neighborhood bar in Burlington’s Old North End, where Ash’s house is. It’s a real hodge podge kind of area. People from all walks of life live and work in close proximity. And the Northender is one of the places where lots of those people might end up in the same room at the same time.

Josh from his barstool
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Josh pulls up a stool at the Northender.

Josh Crane: As one patron named Chris put it:

Chris: It's a working class bar. There's a lot of labor employees here and there's also a lot of technology people that are here as well. It's a vibrant mix, I think.

Josh Crane: If you haven’t been, you should know that the Northender is not a fancy place. There's a bumper sticker on the front door that says, “Start your bender at the Olde Northender.” And across the street is China Express 2. People sometimes bring their takeout in to eat at the bar. In the back, there’s a pool table and darts. And behind the bar, I notice a Cool Whip container with a plant growing out of it, and a sign that says “Sorry, we’re open.”

Start your bender
Burgess Brown
/
Vermont Public
The Northender's iconic bumper sticker.

Josh Crane: And they are open … every day, from 8 a.m., on. I get to the Northender around 6:30 on a wintry Monday evening.

I'm interested in this idea that community doesn't always have to mean close friendships. Maybe it's just having somewhere to go alone, but where you don't feel alone. I want to see what people here have to say.

Pretty soon, a crew of regulars rolls in to watch Jeopardy!

Tommy Dubuc: They like to compete against each other …

Josh Crane: Tommy Dubuc is a longtime bartender. He grew up in Shelburne and South Burlington and started working here in 2013, after more than two decades at a local Irish pub that was popular with UVM students.

Tommy Dubuc: Time to get out of the college bars. My kids were college students. I didn't wanna be near them ... no.

Josh Crane: The sign behind the bar that reads " Beware of Attack Bartender" does not quite match Tommy’s vibe.  He's 63, wearing a baseball hat and a tucked in plaid button-down. He refers to himself as the "bar dad." He keeps an extra stash of chocolate behind the bar in case anyone’s having an especially bad day.

Tommy Dubuc: You know, I'm too old to fight, and I'm too fat to chase you. So let's keep everyone happy and peaceful, and life is good. I'm simple and I like simple things.

Josh Crane: Do you ever forget who people are? Like, how do you remember everyone?

Tommy Dubuc: Oh, God, I sure do. I cheat, I have their credit card. They always say, "How do you remember my name?" I go, "I have your card!"

Josh Crane: Tommy's being modest. As far as I can tell, he remembers everyone's orders — Jack and coke, G&T, wine spritzer with vodka — sometimes sliding drinks to new arrivals across the bar without so much as a word.

Tommy working
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Tommy chats with patrons whose names he absolutely remembers without checking their credit cards.

Tommy Dubuc: I refer to it as, like, a cozy neighborhood bar. People know people. They know what they're doing. They know about their life, you know. They come here because they want a place where it's like Cheers. You want to know their name. They want someone to be seen, to be heard, you know.

Josh Crane: After Jeopardy! wraps up, a group of UVM students sits down next to me. It doesn't take long for them to ask why I'm sitting at the bar with a giant microphone.

Maria Muller: Are you reviewing this place? What are you doing?

Josh Crane: Maria Muller is a UVM senior from Minnesota. She's been to the Northender a couple of times. Tonight, she and her housemates have wandered in hoping to watch the Minnesota Timberwolves game.

Maria Muller: Any chance you guys got the Wolves game? Timberwolves? NBA?

Josh Crane: Tommy says — they don’t.

Maria Muller: That's OK. No worries.

Josh Crane: I tell them I'm working on a story about loneliness. Maria and her housemate, Isabelle Neve, also a senior, and also a transplant from Minnesota, have thoughts.

Maria Muller: We talk about this all the time.

Isabelle Neve: All the time.

Maria Muller: I think being alone is having the option to be with people when you want to be. I think being lonely is feeling as though you don't have the option of experiencing life with other people.

Isabelle Neve: We've spent our time in the past few years building a community, but like, we're all about to go separate ways for a very long time, and I think a lot of us are very afraid of the loneliness that probably will come from having to rebuild community all over again.

But I think it definitely is something that's on our minds now coming up, of like, loneliness can come again. Even though we've found community here, it doesn't mean that it's like, you know, we've solved the loneliness of our, of our lifetime. 

I felt lonely, definitely, when I first got here, just because none of the people around me know who I am. But over time they have come to know me. And so I think like, we've, we've built the tools to get out of loneliness, I guess.

Josh Crane: Maria and Isabelle tell me they've been grateful for the community spirit they've found since coming to Burlington.

Maria Muller: I think they do kind of emphasize, like, third spaces and the importance of meeting others. And there's a lot of cool opportunities when you look for them of like, I don't know, like run clubs and, um, like queer community stuff.

Isabelle Neve: I'm from the suburbs of Minneapolis, and there definitely is not that kind of sense of community there at all.

Josh Crane: One of the ways Maria and Isabelle have turned community-building into something of a practice is by embracing a sort of small town-Vermont ethos, even while living in the state’s biggest city. Like sitting on their front porch and saying hi to everyone who walks by.

Josh Crane: Does it work?

Isabelle Neve: Yeah.

Maria Muller: Sometimes it's weird, but …

Isabelle Neve: You got to get over the weird.

Maria Muller: A lot of the times I think, yeah, people are excited to talk to someone knowing that somebody else wants to talk to them.

Maria Muller: We’re all neighbors and smile at your neighbors!

Isabelle Neve: Yeah!

Josh Crane: Bartender Tommy points at one of his regulars a couple stools over.

Tommy Dubuc: Well, this guy right here especially, almost daily he cooks something and brings it in to share with the crowd.

Josh Crane: Tommy says this guy, Chris, doesn't bring traditional bar food, either. Last week it was stuffed clams.

Chris: I used to do a lot of, uh, mass production cooking.

Josh Crane: This is Chris. He used to be a cook and owned a restaurant.

Not only does he bring in food to share, but he’ll make sure that the regulars who don't have enough money to eat well leave the bar with a full takeout container-worth of home-cooked food.

And looking out for people here is personal for Chris.

Chris: I was born and brought up in the neighborhood, about less than a block away from here. As a child, I used to ride my bike around the block all the time. (Laughter) So, uh, I guess you could say I'm familiar with the place.

Josh Crane: Chris knows the place, he knows the people, and he has a routine. He says his favorite days to come here are, quote, "the ones that end in Y."

Chris: It’s a place I frequent, yeah. I come here for Jeopardy! and for an afternoon social hour.

Josh Crane: With this community, Chris says he never feels lonely.

Chris: No. Gosh, no. No. There's always something to do and go to. I think loneliness is what you make of it, I think. I mean, there’s tons of volunteerism that can be done. Come here to see my favorite bartender, Tom, you know?

Tommy Dubuc: Yeah. He's been drinking.

(Door opens)

Josh Crane: I head out front to the small wooden porch, where I find a more recent Northender convert leaning against the railing. Adam Carnes has been coming here for about four years.

Adam on the front porch of the Olde North Ender
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Adam gets some fresh air on the front porch at the Northender.

Adam Carnes: I feel like there's good people here.

Josh Crane: Adam is a painter, sculptor and carpenter.

Josh Crane: Do you come here alone?

Adam Carnes: Yeah. Yeah. I think I've come here with friends, like, maybe, like, twice. So yeah. I enjoy, like, popping in here, seeing who's here, and then just, like, you know, stroll off to … (Laughter)

Josh Crane: Do you feel ever anxious, like, coming here alone, or it’s, it’s comfortable?

Adam Carnes: You know what, when you put it like that, um, there's many places where I'll go by myself and there's that instant anxiety of like, "Hey, I'm an outsider and I don't know anyone here."

But I feel like every single time that I've come here, no matter how long of a time it's been since I've last, like, you know, entertained the idea of coming here, everyone's been more than welcome. 

Josh Crane:  Adam says part of what makes the Northender welcoming is that it doesn't seem to be trying to be anything other than what it is.

And because there's no big scene or social performance to navigate here, Adam says it's easy to meet new people.

Adam Carnes: It’s nice, like, you know, you can make different connections each night, each time that you enter the space. So yeah, I think it's, it's kind of beautiful to have that.

Josh Crane: Do you ever feel lonely?

Adam Carnes: What, here? Or in … oh, yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean, Vermont's very isolating, period, you know? I mean, also, coming from New York to here, it's like, yeah, the, it's very different.

Josh Crane: Isolating, like physically isolating?

Adam Carnes: Physically isolating, uh, mentally isolating, uh, kind of staggering in some ways. But at the same time, just being able to walk in somewhere and kind of feel like, OK, well, you know, if they're welcoming, like, this feels like home.

Like, it's a little less, a little less intimidating. So it's good to have something like that to return to.

Adam on the front porch of the Olde Northender
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Adam says it's easy to make new connections at the Olde Northender.

Josh Crane:  Adam talks about the relief of having somewhere to go, especially when the rest of life can feel isolating. But I wonder if there are people who spend a lot of time here, see familiar faces, even feel welcome — and still feel alone.

As I reclaim my barstool inside, I notice Tommy pointing me toward a guy at the other end of the bar. He's eating a burger and drinking a beer by himself. His name is Austin. He works at the hospital and comes here most days after work to unwind.

Austin: Everybody's got their own way to decompress, but I like going to a place where I'm not talking about my work, I'm not talking about medicine.

Josh Crane: Austin moved to Vermont a few years ago. He was in a longtime relationship, which ended last year.

Josh Crane: Do you ever feel lonely?

Austin: Yeah, all the time. Sometimes you're kind of like, you know, it'd be nice to have somebody who, who knows you and maybe cares about you a little bit, you know? Eventually it’s like, eh, it'd be nice to like maybe have a little bit of deeper perspective on things. And I love all these people here, they're all nice, but they don't really care about what I do afterwards, you know?

Josh Crane:  He looks around at the people in the bar. They're friendly. They're familiar. But when he leaves here, their lives go on, and so does his.

Austin: There's probably a little hole in there somewhere, you know? And maybe I'm filling that with coming here and hanging out versus, like, trying to meet people and all that, you know?

I've known Tommy now since I, I moved here four years ago, and just a salt of the earth kinda guy. It's hard to beat that, you know?

Josh Crane: Like a lot of my conversations tonight, this one ends right back where it started: with Tommy.

Tommy Dubuc: See you Austin.

Tommy the bartender

Josh Crane:  I've spent most of the evening watching bartender Tommy Dubuc work the room. He remembers people's orders, asks about their lives, makes sure everyone's taken care of. He's not just behind the bar. He's at the center of this little community, and a big part of what holds it together.

But there's something I didn't know when I first walked in. He's been sober for 26 years.

Tommy Dubuc: To be honest with you, when I first started, I was a party— I was a single guy with no attachments and nothing going on. And so I was right there in the mix. And I am a recovering alcoholic, addict, so I haven't drank and done anything in 26 years.

Tommy smiling
Josh Crane
/
Vermont Public
Tommy "bar dad" Dubuc.

Tommy Dubuc: I love people, and that, that was probably the thing. I would never drink at home alone. I always had to be out to be social. And where'd you go? I would go to my place. I would be at McKee's or Finnigan's or, um, doing that, because that's where my space to be myself and forget about everything else. It was, and my thing was it was the cure and the cause of all of my problems.

Josh Crane: He says it was the "cure" of his problems because he met his wife in a bar. She’d come to Finnigan’s, the bar he was working at, to study. She’d sit in the corner, read a book and drink an Irish beer. Tommy asked her out three times before she said yes.

Tommy Dubuc: We now have twin daughters. We've been married almost 30 years, and it's the best thing ever. You know? Stay straight. Again, it gave me a purpose.

Josh Crane:  Tommy met his wife when he was working at a bar. The godparents of their twin daughters are people he met in bars, too.

And he's also seen lifelong relationships develop between patrons at bars.  He tells me about a couple who started coming in to the Northender about eight years ago, when they were dating.

Tommy Dubuc: And they came in when they got engaged, and they came in on their wedding night.

Josh Crane:  For their wedding, the couple had customized pint glasses. They brought a couple of them to the bar that night. And Tommy kept them behind the bar just for them.

Tommy Dubuc: And every time they came in, I would serve them in these glasses.

Josh Crane:  But a few years ago, Tommy faced some serious health challenges. In the span of five years, he dealt with lung and prostate cancer, kidney failure and a brain tumor.  He spent the better part of several years away from the Northender before eventually returning this past year, cancer free.

Josh Crane: What was it like, what was it like coming back?

Tommy Dubuc: It was great for me. Um, it was like I hadn't, hadn't missed a beat.

Josh Crane: Two of the people who made Tommy's return especially meaningful were the husband and wife with the special glasses. They approached Tommy with an idea:

Tommy Dubuc: I came back and the wife came up to me, and she goes, "I love my husband, and we work together, we live together, but we don't get to see you. So we're picking one day that you're working, when you're coming back, and we're picking a day, and that's gonna be our date night."

Josh Crane:  They settled on Tuesdays. And they've kept it up ever since. Tommy calls them his “Tuesday Date Crew.”

Tommy Dubuc: And it's just people that you've developed a relationship with, that there's mutual care, and you know how they're gonna be. You know how they're gonna act. You know there's not gonna be drama.

I have, like, two biological kids and, like, 88 adopted. And I, and I mean that sincerely because I, I do care for all of them, you know, in their own whatever way. Like, just like a father would with their kids.

Backwards hat guy: You are the bar dad, Tommy. You are.

Josh Crane: “You are the bar dad," says one of Tommy's younger regulars. And like a true bar dad, Tommy is sure to give him some advice.

Backwards hat guy: I gotta do more traveling, man.

Tommy Dubuc: You know, I tell you young kids, do it now when you're young. Don't wait until you retire and think, you know, "I've got all this money and all this time." Because then you're too old and sicker usually. Go do it now with no attachments. See the world when you can run around and be crazy. Live your life.

The Olde North Ender sign
Burgess Brown
/
Vermont Public
The Olde Northender Pub on North Street.

Loading...

Credits

This episode was reported by Josh Crane. Editing and production from the rest of the BLS team: Sabine Poux and Burgess Brown. Our intern is Sarah Bokelberg. Executive producer is Angela Evancie. Theme music by Ty Gibbons; other music by Blue Dot Sessions.

Special thanks to Liam Elder-Connors, Erica Heilman, Bobby Pryor, Anna Guenther, Jesse Pollard and everyone we spoke to about the Vermont Public poll: Cristine, Bryan, Philip, Marylynne, Erika and Jack.

As always, our journalism is better when you’re a part of it:

Brave Little State is a production of Vermont Public and a proud member of the NPR Network.

Josh Crane is part of Vermont Public's Engagement Journalism team. He's the senior producer and managing editor for Brave Little State, a podcast based on questions about Vermont that have been asked and voted on by the audience, and runs Vermont Public's Sonic ID project.