The Democrats who will wield a supermajority in the Vermont Senate next year have elected Washington County Sen. Andrew Perchlik to serve as their chamber’s next leader.
Perchlik, who currently chairs the powerful Senate Appropriations Committee, will succeed outgoing Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth when the full Legislature convenes in January.
The pro tem functions as the agenda-setter in chief for the Senate and also sits on the three-person panel responsible for making committee assignments.
The 58-year-old Marshfield resident has quickly ascended the ranks in Montpelier despite his soft-spoken, mild-mannered bearing. In a speech to fellow Senate Democrats Monday, Perchlik vowed to maintain the cool-headed diplomacy that’s characterized his leadership during his first three terms in office.
“Hard work creates its own heat,” he said. “And a good pro tem doesn’t need to bring more heat.”
But Perchlik also issued a warning: “Don’t mistake kindness for weakness.”
He told Vermont Public he felt compelled to offer the admonition because of concerns he heard from colleagues when he was courting their votes.
“When I talked to senators about (being) pro tem, I heard that one of the criticisms … was that I was too nice, too chill,” he said. “So I wanted to remind people to not mistake niceness or kindness for weakness.”
Perchlik had until recently faced competition for the Senate’s top job. Senate Majority Leader Kesha Ram Hinsdale dropped her bid for pro tem shortly before Senate Democrats met Monday. It was their first official caucus since their party picked up four seats in the chamber earlier this month.
“He and I have very different leadership styles,” Ram Hinsdale said. “And it became clear that there was a place for me to travel the state, work on cost-of-living matters and affordability … that doesn’t come with the kind of leadership-from-behind that is the hallmark of the president pro tem.”
The return of Democratic supermajorities in both the House and Senate will give the party outsize influence in Montpelier over the next two years. Perchlik said Democrats can leverage their veto-proof majority most effectively if the House and Senate establish a shared agenda.
“We are more powerful if we think of ourselves as 123 people. That’s us, plus the 102 members of the Democratic caucus in the House,” Perchlik said.
He said Democrats also need to be mindful not to repeat the mistakes that cost them their supermajority status in 2024. And he said he looks forward to collaborating with Republican Gov. Phil Scott and GOP minorities in the Legislature.
“We lost the trust, I’d say, of many Vermonters who didn’t believe that we were really working collaboratively with everyone to deliver on solutions that lifted all Vermonters up,” he said. “I think we should be careful not to let that happen again.”
Democrats elected Windsor County Sen. Becca White Monday to replace Ram Hinsdale as majority leader. White said Democrats’ increased numbers will allow the caucus to “move with a collective vision forward in a way that we couldn’t prior to this election.”
That vision will center on the affordability issues that drove voters’ decisions at the ballot box earlier this month.
“We know that many Vermonters are hurting economically. The cost of living has become too much, too high for too many,” Perchlik said. “Future generations are questioning whether they can afford to build their lives here, and Vermonters sent us here to make Vermonters’ lives better.”
It’s still unclear how pre-session platitudes will translate into policy next year. Universal primary care, property tax relief and housing will top the legislative agenda for many Senate Democrats next year. They’ll also have to plot next steps on an education reform law that’s already facing pushback from many Vermont communities.
Legislation enacted in June would see the state take over school spending decisions from local communities. Recent polling indicates the proposal — called a “foundation formula” — is exceedingly unpopular with Vermonters.
“Right now the foundation formula is still in the process of being thought through,” Bennington County Sen. Seth Bongartz, the Democratic chair of the Senate Education Committee, said Monday. “Where this is all headed, I can’t really tell you.”
House Democrats will elect a successor to outgoing Speaker Jill Krowinski when they meet in early December.
Republicans have already elected Caledonia County Sen. Scott Beck to continue as minority leader in the Senate, and Poultney Rep. Pattie McCoy will stay on as minority leader in the House.
In the only contested leadership race Monday, Chittenden County Sen. Ginny Lyons narrowly survived a challenge from Addison County Sen. Ruth Hardy to continue as the third member of the Committee on Committees, which also includes the pro tem and lieutenant governor. The panel is responsible for making committee assignments and selecting chairs and vice chairs.